Room on the Broom: is there room in your life for a perfect picture book? {Picture Book Review}

Room on the Broom picture book review

Room on the Broom by Julia Donaldson and Axel Scheffler {Picture Book Review}

A generous witch shares her broom in this wonderfully illustrated and delightfully rhymed picture book.

Age Range: 3-5, 4-8

Overall Rating: 5 stars

Literary Value: 5 stars

Artistic Value: 5 stars

 

Themes of Truth, Beauty, and Goodness

Generosity, helping friends, helping strangers, teamwork, triumphing over adversity

Discussion Questions

How did the witch show generosity to the animals?

How were the animals good friends to the witch?

Academic Tie-ins

This one is just for fun!

Parents might want to know

If you’re not into witches and dragons and magic potions, you probably want to skip this one.

Spectacular Illustrations

From one of the best picture book author/illustrator teams, this gem from Julia Donaldson and Axel Scheffler, creators of The Gruffalo, is one of my family’s all-time favorite picture books. 

 

This is one of those picture books that you can enjoy from across the room – without seeing any of the pictures. Julia Donaldson is a masterful poet using meter and rhyme and all of the literary devices to create a book that is a delight to read aloud. 

 

This is also a picture book that a non-reader can enjoy on his own. Curled up on a big comfy couch a young child can revel in Axel Scheffler’s illustrations which tell the whole story in delightful detail. The pictures are whimsical and energetic and you can tell exactly how the characters are feeling by the expressions on their faces.

 

Combining the talents of these two artists creates a picture book that is more than the sum of its parts. Without feeling at all preachy, this is a tale of true generosity. Each time the witch is asked to share her broom, she does, no questions asked. When the witch needs help, the animals help her. When her life is in peril, they work together to save her. And they all live happily ever after. 

 

The Pumpkin Fair: Fall festival fun makes you feel like you’re there! {Picture Book Review}

The Pumpkin Fair by Eve Bunting

The Pumpkin Fair by Eve Bunting and Eileen Christelow {Picture Book Review}

A warty little pumpkin wins the most-loved prize.

Age Range: 4-8

Overall Rating: 4 stars

Literary Value: 3 stars

Artistic Value: 5 stars

 

Themes of Truth, Beauty, and Goodness

 Siblings having fun and celebrating together. Poetic language.

Discussion Questions

Why do you think the little pumpkin wanted to be fierce?

Who was the pumpkin’s role model? Do you think he was a good role model? Why or why not?

What are things that make you feel big and important?

Academic Tie-ins

Science (change, pumpkin life cycle, fall)

Parents might want to know

There is a scene where the children dance in a circle around the pumpkin “singing a song to the terrific, terrible pumpkin with the zigzag grin.” 

Spectacular Illustrations

This beautifully illustrated picture book captures the wholesome fun of a local fall festival with all of its costumes, contests, games, and pumpkin-themed fun.

It’s a rhyming book, but, honestly, the rhyme scheme is fairly clunky in parts. There also isn’t much plot to this book. A little girl takes her pumpkin to the pumpkin fair knowing that it isn’t the biggest, the smallest, the prettiest, or the most creatively presented. But she really loves it anyway, because it’s hers and she grew it. Somehow, at least one of the judges sees this love, and rewards it a ribbon.

So why am I reviewing it? Why do I love it?

I really love the illustrations in this book. They are so detailed, and colorful, and everyone looks so happy. You can feel the bright sun and the cool breeze. You can hear the pumpkin seeds being spit and the cheers of the tug-o-war. I can even almost smell the funnel cakes, but maybe that’s just me.

The illustrations make you feel like you’re right there in the middle of all of the best fun that the best of small-town America has to offer at the best time of year. It’s the perfect addition to your sweater weather picture book collection.

Book Review: The Fierce Yellow Pumpkin is just spooky enough

Book Review: The Fierce Yellow Pumpkin by Margaret Wise Brown

The tale of a special place where children create a grown-up world of their own.

Age: 3-5, 4-8

Overall rating: 3 ½ stars

Literary value: 4 stars

Artistic value: 3 ½ stars

Themes of Truth, Beauty, and Goodness

 Siblings having fun and celebrating together. Poetic language.

Discussion Questions

Why do you think the little pumpkin wanted to be fierce?

Who was the pumpkin’s role model? Do you think he was a good role model? Why or why not?

What are things that make you feel big and important?

Academic Tie-ins

Science (change, pumpkin life cycle, fall)

Parents might want to know

There is a scene where the children dance in a circle around the pumpkin “singing a song to the terrific, terrible pumpkin with the zigzag grin.” 

This is a peculiar little book. The language is delightful, as one might expect from the beloved author of Goodnight Moon. The repetition of “fat little, round little, orange little pumpkin” and phrases like “fierce, ferocious gobble-gooble face” make it a real joy to read out loud. The illustrations are captivating. The drawings of the children have an oddness to them, but the pictures of the mice and the pumpkin and the scenes of the fields with the scarecrow are all very engaging. 

 

What makes the book peculiar is the protagonist. Our fat little, round little, orange little pumpkin wants to be big. Fair enough. But he also wants to be mean. In the end, he gets his wish. He becomes a “terrific, terrible pumpkin with [a] zigzag grin.” And, as he wished, the mice run when they see him.

 

If you are looking for a “spooky season” book for your little ones that isn’t too dark or scary, this fits the bill. My sensitive little boy (now 19!) gasped when the pumpkin’s fierce face was revealed, which is particularly amusing given the drawing is pretty much the same as the one on the cover of the book. The prose and illustrations also perfectly capture the crisp yet dreary feeling of late October. The book more than delivers as an addition to the Halloween atmosphere.

 

You can read it for that alone – enjoy the illustrations and the lyrical language and then let it go on its merry way. Or, you can dig a little deeper and wonder together why this pumpkin wants to be mean and scary. It could be an interesting conversation starter, especially if you have a little pumpkin who likes to be scary.

Verified by MonsterInsights